Maternity ward closures and infant health outcomes, maternal health outcomes, and birth procedures

HERO WP 2024/2: Astrid de Linde, Jostein Grytten, Irene Skau, and Jonas Minet Kinge

Abstract

We analyze the short- and long-term impacts of maternity ward closures on health and education outcomes, hospital procedures, and fertility. Our study makes use of registry data that covers every delivery in Norway from 1981 through 2019. Among those directly experiencing a closure, we find in the short-term a small decline 5-minute Apgar score and increased probability of birth outside institution. This slight drop in Apgar is not reflected in the other available health indicators and we therefore hypothesize it reflects different institutional scoring standards as opposed to a health effect. For long-term outcomes, we find that experiencing a closure as an infant results in a 1 percentage point increase in beginning high school by 16, but does not lead to a change in the likelihood of graduating by age 22. Furthermore, for those infants assigned female at birth, experiencing closures as an infant does not change the likelihood of giving birth as an adult or experiencing negative health conditions during pregnancy. Given that these conditions are themselves potential risk factors for newborn health, our results do not point to evidence for an intergenerational effect of closures. We hypothesize that an effective prenatal screening process and robust health and social services may mitigate the effect of closures and thus account for a limited treatment effect. Our paper is among the first to look at both the short and long-term implications of closures and suggests further avenues to study among labor, education, and health outcomes.

JEL-Classification: I11, I14, I18, J13

Keywords: maternity care, closures, centralization, registry data 

Last ned rapport

Publisert 12. juni 2024 10:42 - Sist endret 12. juni 2024 10:42